This paper proposes a short apprehension of the reflections of one of the most important progressive islamic scholars, the egyptian theologian ali abderraziq. Findings from surveys in egypt and tunisia in 2011 are discussed in greater detail in relation to postarab spring developments in the two countries. Meyer, katherine, rizzo, helen, and ali, yousef, islam and the extension of citizenship rights to women in kuwait, journal for the scientific study of religion 37 march 1998. Whereas democracy requires openness, pluralism, and tolerance of diversity, islam, he and others argue, encourages intellectual conformity and an uncritical acceptance of authority tessler, 2003. Mark tessler, the origins of popular support for islamist movements. This volume includes chapters examining several broad themes. Broad continuing trends include strong support for democracy, understandings of democracy that emphasize economic considerations, and a division of opinion about islams political role. Lily zubaidah rahim, malaysia chair for islam in southeast asia, center for christian. Do islamic orientations influence attitudes toward. For some scholars of the middle east, democracy and islam are fundamentally at odds. Early in its history, islam had a presence in europe.
Plattner the global divergence of democracies johns hopkins, 2001, pp. It is the spirit of service to the people and their welfare that is the. Explaining support for undemocratic leaders in democracies in the middle east andrew heiss1 1. Eightysix percent of muslims believe democracy is the best form of government, and majorities of arabs admire the wests political freedoms, democracy, work ethic, and economic progress, according to a study published in the january 2008 issue of the journal of democracy. Article information, pdf download for do islamic orientations influence attitudes. Mark tessler faculty people center for political studies. Explaining support for undemocratic leaders in democracies in. Commentators can generally be divided into pessimists and cautious optimists. Jaimie bleck, associate professor of political science, university of notre dame.
Democratization and authoritarianism in the arab world. The impact of religious orientations on attitudes toward democracy in four arab countries, comparative. Comparative politics reading list schar school of policy. The impact of religious orientations on attitudes toward democracy in four arab countries. The impact of religious orientations on attitudes toward democracy in four arab countries article pdf available in comparative politics 343 april. In discussing the question of whether islam can be compatible with democracy, tessler 2002 states that islam will have strong political implications because it is a religion of laws pertaining. In the course of the scholarly discourse, debate has emerged as to whether the thickly liberal rule of law can survive in a society where the legal system is undergoing islamization. In democratization and authoritarianism in the arab world, leading scholars address the questions posed by this period of historic change in the middle east and north africa.
Fukuyama 2001 advances a cultural theory, arguing that islam has very little in common with modern democracy. Nov 16, 2015 eightysix percent of muslims believe democracy is the best form of government, and majorities of arabs admire the wests political freedoms, democracy, work ethic, and economic progress, according to a study published in the january 2008 issue of the journal of democracy. Islam and authoritarianism world politics cambridge core. The impact of religious orientations on attitudes toward democracy in four arab countries is an article based on the analysis of the surveys made in different islamic countries about the relation between islam and democracy. Do education and income affect support for democracy in. Definitions of democracy vary considerably, however, with some citizens emphasizing government accountability and political freedoms and while others stress instrumental considerations, including effectiveness in meeting economic. Mark tessler ronald inglehart there is a widespread desire for democracy among the iraqi public, but when it comes to the roles of religion, ethnicity, and gender equality in iraqs new democracy, attitudes are. Beyond feminism and islamism pdf download full pdf. Do islamic orientations influence attitudes toward democracy. Islam and democracy eliane ursula ettmueller abstract. The research reports collected in this volume examine the nature and determinants of citizen attitudes toward governance and democracy, the political role of islam, gender equality, and international conflict. Evidence from central asia, journal of democracy, vol. In democracy, war, and peace in the middle east, edited by david garnham and mark tessler, pp.
Along with broad support for democracy, there is a deep and nearly equal division of opinion about the extent to which, and the way in which, islam should play a role in political affairs. It focuses on his work about islam and the fundamentals of power, published in 1925. The prospects for democracy in north africa and the middle east, dale f. Beyond feminism and islamism pdf download full pdf read. Many conventional assumptions about islam and politics do not.
Plattner this volume gathers essays by leading scholars and principals of regional publicopinion surveys, known as barometers, which are making possible the first systematic, worldwide study of how citizens think about democracy and weigh it against other forms of government. How people view democracy johns hopkins university press books. Islam and democracy in the middle east the impact of religious orientations on attitudes toward democracy in four arab countries mark tessler discussions about democracy in the arab world often include attention to the political orientations of ordinary men and women. The impact of religious orientations on attitudes toward democracy in four arab countries m tessler comparative politics, 337354, 2002. In islam, democracy, and the state in north africa, edited by john entelis, pp. The political orientations of ordinary citizens in the arab and muslim middle east have engaged mark tessler since the late 1960s. This chapter positions itself in a way that reflects on how democratic structures as well as a belief in democracy.
He has studied andor conducted field research in tunisia, israel, morocco, egypt, and palestine west bank and gaza. In this threepart edited volume, tessler presents a nuanced investigation of middle eastern attitudes and values surrounding democratic ideology, democratization, political culture, the political economy, and the role of islam in government, peace, and armed conflict. Explaining support for undemocratic leaders in democracies. April 30, 20 polsci 733 in 2008 amaney jamal and mark tessler, coprincipal investigators of the arab barometer project,2 published preliminary. Islam, social justice, and democracy politics and religion. A political economy analysis, in islam, democracy, and the state in north africa, edited by john entelis bloomington. In 2008 amaney jamal and mark tessler, coprincipal investigators. For some scholars of the middle east, democracy and islam. Mark tessler s highly praised, comprehensive, and balanced history of the israelipalestinian conflict from the earliest times to the presentupdated through the first years of the 21st centuryprovides a constructive framework for understanding recent developments and assessing the prospects for future peace. Connections among attitudes toward democracy, the military and islam, democratization, vol. What leads some ordinary arab men and women to approve of. The impact of religious orientations on attitudes toward democracy in four arab countries comparative politics, pp. How people view democracy johns hopkins university press.
Michael bonner, megan reif, and mark tessler, editors. To call islam antidemocracy by citing a brief verse noncontextually is odd. East politics, edited by mark tessler, with jodi nachtwey and anne banda. Eldersveld collegiate professor department of political science university of michigan 505 south state street ann arbor, michigan 481091045 734 6159149 fax. The politics of human rights in the maghreb, susan waltz 75 5. Unfortunately, and due to unforeseen circumstances, this panel event has been cancelled. Mark tessler, on the other hand, recently conducted surveys in the middle east that prove this theory to be incorrect. Mark tessler, islam and democracy in the middle east. Eldersveld collegiate professor of political science. Tessler, mark, a history of the israelipalestinian conflict.
Eldersveld collegiate professor of political science, um. Examined with data from the first and second wave of arab barometer surveys are support for democracy, understandings of democracy, desires for reform, values associated with a democratic political culture, views about the political role of islam, and the relationship between. The midterm is worth 40% of your grade, and the final is worth 40% of your grade. New findings on arabs and democracy journal of democracy. Mark tesslers highly praised, comprehensive, and balanced history of the israelipalestinian conflict from the earliest times to the presentupdated through the first years of the 21st centuryprovides a constructive framework for understanding recent developments and assessing the prospects for future peace. Lily zubaidah rahim, malaysia chair for islam in southeast asia, center for christianmuslim understanding, georgetown. How people view democracy edited by larry diamond and marc f. In islam, democracy, and the state in north africa, edited by j. Public opinion in the middle east indiana university press. Evidence from belgium, comparative political studies, vol. Do islamic orientations influence attitudes toward democracy in the. The impact of religious orientations on attitudes toward democracy in four arab countries authors. Tessler s research indicated the majority of people in the middle east want a combination of democracy and islam.
Jodi nachtwey and mark tessler, explaining womens support for political islam. The final exam will cover the postmidterm material. Turabi was in the united states for a private visit in may, 1992. July 21 mark tessler article islam and democracy in the. Chapter 3 examines the influence of islam on attitudes toward democracy among ordinary arab men and women. On may 10, he was the guest of the world and islam studies enterprise wise and the middle east committee of the university of south florida in tampa. The arab barometer finds widespread support for democracy in arab world. He specializes in comparative politics and middle east studies. Islam, is typically called eastern in ways the other two monotheistic religions, judaism and christianity, also originating in the east, are not. Islam and democracy in the middle east rochelle terman. Mar 12, 2020 unfortunately, and due to unforeseen circumstances, this panel event has been cancelled. A central asian perspective, journal of democracy, 4 october 2002, p. Mark tesslers curriculum vitae institute for social research.
Popular views about islam and politics in the arab world. Utilizing his newly constructed carnegie middle east governance and islam dataset, which has been placed in the public domain for use by other researchers epub, mark tessler formulates and tests hypotheses about the views held by ordinary citizens, offering insights into the individual and countrylevel factors that shape attitudes toward. Survey research and the political orientations of ordinary citizens. The relationship between islam and politics is arguably the most important and hotlydebated issue pertaining to governance in the presentday arab world. Islam and democracy at the individual level of analysis. New findings on arabs and democracy mark tessler, amaney jamal. Sanford school of public policy, duke university, andrew. These findings are relevant to arguments about democracy and islam in the arab world. The origins of popular support for islamist movements. Program in political science of the city university of new york stable url.
1312 1280 739 832 474 1061 1255 23 1182 1366 923 849 79 337 1200 1438 354 1497 1070 130 1399 645 1466 367 719 1400 1172 801 1245 1039 1283 1124 1298 827 778 765 798